Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

News

Four women in elite Dallas police unit sidelined from key tactical duties, federal suit alleges

Four of the five women assigned to an elite Dallas police unit were barred from some of its most dangerous assignments, a decision two of the officers say was driven by sex discrimination.

Two officers allege sex discrimination after a police review found supervisors failed to document reasons for the restrictions.

By Chase Rogers,Staff Writer

The Earle Cabell Federal Building and Courthouse houses the Dallas Division of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. Two Dallas police officers filed a lawsuit in the division Nov. 10, alleging the department restricted their tactical duties because of their sex.Smiley N. Pool/Staff Photographer

Four of the five women assigned to an elite Dallas police unit were barred from some of its most dangerous assignments, a decision two of the officers say was driven by sex discrimination.

The March 2025 restrictions kept the women from participating in certain high-risk arrests, although an internal police review the following month found that supervisors had not adequately documented the reasons for the decision.

Now, two of the officers are suing the city and five department officials, alleging they were singled out because they were women and faced retaliation after challenging their treatment.

The federal lawsuit, filed Nov. 10 in Dallas, describes what the officers say was a pattern of unequal treatment in the department’s fugitive unit, including remarks about their gender and restrictions on their duties.

The two officers, Senior Cpl. Kimberly Howard and Officer Meredith Leftwich, have more than 30 years of combined service with Dallas police. Their unit serves high-risk arrest and search warrants and is considered one of the department’s more sought-after assignments.

The allegations come as the Dallas Police Women’s Association has raised broader concerns about the treatment of female officers, including the department’s handling earlier this year of a sergeant who sent himself a sexually explicit video of a female officer from her phone.

City and police spokespeople declined to comment. The five department officials being sued, including Maj. Gerald Smalley, either declined to comment or did not respond to requests for comment. Smalley oversaw the fugitive unit at the time and has since been reassigned to lead the crime scene division.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

The four women were barred from serving on entry teams and taking tactical roles in high-risk arrests but could continue performing other duties, including surveillance and prisoner transport, according to the lawsuit.

It alleges that Howard’s physical stature was cited as a reason for restricting her duties. Another woman in the unit was described as “too nice to pull the trigger.”

Howard and Leftwich challenged the restrictions through an internal grievance, leading to a department review that found supervisors had failed to adequately and promptly document the performance concerns used to justify their decision. 

All four women were restored to full operational status in April 2025, according to the lawsuit.

The review did not conclude that the women had been discriminated against. But JoDee Neil, an attorney representing Howard and Leftwich, said the lack of timely documentation was a “clear signal” of discrimination.

“There was nothing in their files to indicate that these women were anything less than fully operational,” Neil said in an interview with The Dallas Morning News.

Howard and Leftwich also allege they faced retaliation after returning to full operational status. Leftwich says she was later excluded from certain assignments.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Related: Dallas police chief’s first year brought falling crime — and rising political pressures

The other two women affected by the restrictions did not join the grievance or the lawsuit.

Neil cited the department’s handling of the explicit video case as further evidence of what she considers unequal treatment of women in the department.

The sergeant’s supervisors recommended punishments ranging from a one-day suspension to demotion. Police Chief Daniel Comeaux ultimately suspended him for 15 days.

Neil contrasted that punishment with the restrictions imposed on her clients, whose records she said were clean. “The injustice of it just really kept me awake at night and contributed to our decision to file the suit,” she said.

Howard and Leftwich are seeking damages and lost pay. They also want the city to rescind the memo restricting their duties and prohibit its use in future personnel decisions involving them.


Chase Rogers

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Public Safety Reporter

Chase Rogers covers the Dallas Police Department, Dallas Fire-Rescue, and broader public safety issues in Dallas. He grew up in Granbury and studied journalism at Texas State University in San Marcos. Before joining The News, he reported for the Austin American-Statesman and the Corpus Christi Caller-Times. His work has earned investigative reporting and Freedom of Information awards, including Texas Managing Editor’s Star Reporter of the Year in 2022. He can be reached at 361-239-6527 and on Signal at crogers.95.

ADVERTISEMENT

News Video

IMM Mask Promos

I Messenger Media Radio Shows

ADVERTISEMENT

Related Articles

Health

Feel free to see the liver as a workaholic as it is really a busy guy. From bile production and excretion, metabolism of proteins...

Spotlight Story

Fried Hard Blvd brings big Louisiana flavor to Dallas with its mouthwatering selection of crispy, well-seasoned fried fish, wings, and Cajun comfort food

Spotlight Story

Kendall Karsen’s Upscale Soul Food in Dallas serves up delicious, home-style Southern cooking with generous portions and great prices.

Spotlight Story

If you love Southern comfort food, Ruth Faye's Kitchen is worth checking out! This family-owned business serves delicious fried catfish, flavorful shrimp, homemade burgers,...

Advertisement